• Camryn Cutinello
    SEP 14, 2026

    UNLOCKED

    Illinois’ medical aid in dying law goes into effect after federal judge rejects request to block it

    article-image

    An Illinois law allowing terminally ill patients to medically end their own lives went into effect over the weekend after a federal judge declined to block it. 

    The End-of-Life Options for Terminally Ill Patients Act — which was signed by Gov. JB Pritzker in December and went into effect Sept. 12 — made Illinois the first Midwestern state to legalize medical aid in dying.  

    The controversial measure received attention from advocates and opponents alike. Advocates argue the practice gives patients some choice and can minimize suffering, while opponents expressed concerns about coercion and safe disposal of medication when it is not used.  

    Bill sponsor Sen. Linda Holmes (D-Aurora) — who detailed her own experience watching her parents struggle with terminal diagnoses — said the measure was crafted to include several guardrails to prevent abuse.  

    Under the measure, patients must receive terminal diagnosis from two physicians and have all end-of-life options, such as hospice, explained to them. Doctors are also prohibited from mentioning medical aid in dying unless the patient first brings it up.  

    The physician must also assess the patient’s mental capacity and, if concerned about their mental state, they must refer the patient to a mental health professional.  

    The patient must have two witnesses present when making the request, and at least one could not be an immediate family member, recipient of an estate or an employee of the health center. Friends or coworkers could fulfill that requirement. 

    The request for and administration of the medication can only be done by the patient. If a patient is not physically able to administer the medicine themself, they could not be prescribed it under the law.  

    Physicians who prescribe the medication will be required to report that all the requirements in the bill were met to the Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH). The measure does not require any physician in Illinois to prescribe the medication.  

    The measure also makes it a felony to coerce someone into taking the medication.  

    Despite the guardrails, the End Assisted Suicide coalition and several disability and patients' rights organizations sued Illinois in June seeking to prevent the law from going into effect.  

    The coalition had filed a lawsuit in New York the same day as their Illinois lawsuit was filed. That lawsuit was dismissed in July, and New York’s law went into effect in August.  

    The plaintiffs argued the law is discriminatory against disabled people, saying that physicians could attempt to coerce people with disabilities into requesting the medication.  

    Lead plaintiff Ebony Payne, a Chicago resident who is paralyzed from the neck down and suffers from severe asthma, argued that without medical intervention “she is likely to die within six months” and therefore would qualify for the medication.  

    The state disputed this, saying Payne would not qualify under the act as her condition is still treatable.  

    The plaintiffs requested a preliminary injunction to prevent the law from going into effect.  

    U.S. District Judge John Tharp declined that request Thursday. In his order, he wrote that while the Illinois law does not clarify that someone must be terminal “with or without treatment” like the New York law does, the definition matches laws in Delaware and California.  

    He wrote that district courts have rejected challenges that argue those laws could apply to treatable diseases.  

    “A ‘qualified patient’ must have a ‘terminal’ condition—both ‘incurable and irreversible’— and therefore is not someone whose condition is amenable to treatment,” Tharp wrote in his order. “And it would not be a ‘reasonable medical judgment’ that a person who has a treatable condition ‘will’ die within six months.”  

    Tharp further rejected Payne’s claims that the act would cause her harm, saying “her asserted risk of injury is too speculative and conjectural to satisfy the injury requirement of standing.”  

    He said that doctors are still held to the same standard of care as they have always been, pointing to the provisions that require doctors to explain all options to a patient if they have requested the medication.  

    “Ms. Payne’s intangible injuries rest on her speculation that physicians in Illinois will decide, en masse, to abandon their existing duties to their patients,” Tharp wrote. “She has not persuaded the Court that this is anything other than speculation.”  

    Tharp also removed Pritzker as a defendant at the request of the state, as he is not involved in enforcement of the act. IDPH Dir. Sameer Vohra remains a defendant, as enforcement of the act falls to his department.  

    The plaintiffs now have 30 days to make their case for why the lawsuit should not be dismissed in its entirety.  

    The act still faces a separate legal challenge on similar grounds filed earlier this month by Chicago Cardinal Blase Cupich and two orders of nuns.  

Be the first to comment

Comment here

Or sign in with email

    To comment on our website please login or join

    Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.