The Chicago Board of Elections reports a new record for the first day of early voting with 11,032 votes cast. One especially big turnout: 1,003 votes in the 13th Ward, where Democratic Ward Committeeman and Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan is rallying forces to combat primary challenger Jason Gonzalez.

The Board of Elections has also provided this history of early vote turnout. Below are unofficial ward-by-ward turnout numbers for yesterday as reported by the Board of Elections.

Unofficial Ward-by-Ward Early Voting for Feb. 29, 2016

1	162
2	226
3	386
4	391
5	273
6	239
7	313
8	319
9	284
10	172
11	293
12	115
13	1,003
14	97
15	51
16	76
17	202
18	274
19	419
20	156
21	258
22	80
23	241
24	104
25	157
26	112
27	201
28	162
29	227
30	83
31	98
32	132
33	133
34	356
35	82
36	106
37	153
38	216
39	218
40	181
41	333
42	275
43	296
44	224
45	200
46	177
47	226
48	216
49	159
50	180
	11,037

The Cook County Board’s Legislation and Intergovernmental Relations Committee meets today to vote on several appointments to the Board of Ethics, the Cook County Department of Human Rights and the Cook County Justice Advisory Council, including Chief of the Bureau of Human Resources.

Board President Toni Preckwinkle appointed Velisha Haddox to Chief of the Bureau of Human Resources. She is currently listed as Bureau Chief on the County’s website. Haddox previously worked as Associate and General Counsel in Gov. Pat Quinn’sadministration from 2010 to 2013, where she managed legal issues for the Departments of Labor, Children and Family Services, Corrections, Human Rights, and several others. She also reportedly helped overhaul State’s Worker’s Compensation Act. She also serves on the Board of Directors for South Central Community Services, and has worked at various law firms in Chicago and Philadelphia.

Board of Ethics:

• David Grossman - Founder and CEO of The Grossman Group, a communications consultancy

• Professor Juliet Sorensen - Clinical Associate Professor of Law, Northwestern’s Center for International Human Rights

• Thomas Szromba - Principal Senior Counsel, Litigation at The Boeing Company

Cook County Commission on Human Rights:

• Gia Orr - Director of Community Rights, Relationships and Resources, Chief Results Officer and EEO/AA Officer, State of Illinois

• Amber Smock - Director of Advocacy, Access Living

Cook County Justice Advisory Council:

• Edith Crigler - Associate Executive Director at Chicago Area Project

• Lisa Stephens - Chief Operating Officer, Institute for Nonviolence Chicago

• Dia Weil - former President and Chief Operating Officer of Mercantec, Inc.

The Labor Committee will also meet to vote on a collective bargaining agreementbetween the County and the Illinois Fraternal Order of Police (FOP) representing Deputy Sheriffs in the Cook County Sheriff’s office with a term from December 1, 2012 through November 30, 2017.

And the Workforce, Housing & Community Development Committee will vote on the allocation of four Community Development Block Grant loans totaling $9 million. Loans will cover partial costs of the following projects. The first three are qualified as “Disaster Recovery”:

• $1.3 million to BEDS Plus Care of LaGrange, Illinois for new construction of 20-units of permanent supportive housing for the chronically homeless.  

• $2 million to the Hines Veterans Residences Limited Partnership for new construction of a 52-unit multi-family rental housing project in Hines, Illinois.

• $3.2 million to Ford Heights Cooperative, Inc. to support renovation and flood mitigation of a 100-unit single-family rental cooperative housing project in Ford Heights.

• $2.5 million to Related Affordable, Inc. This project loan will be utilized to support HOME-eligible project costs incurred during the rehabilitation of a 145-unit multi-family rental housing project in Park Forest, IL.

Ald. Will Burns (4) sent his resignation to City Clerk Susana Mendoza yesterday, dated Feb 10, putting an end to his time on City Council with a couple sentences: “I am writing you to tender my resignation from the Chicago City Council effective February 29, 2016. It has been my great honor and privilege to serve the people of the Fourth Ward and the City of Chicago.” Burns’ new job as senior advisor and director of Midwest policy at Airbnb starts today.

Rather than preserve his account for posterity, or re-direct followers, Burns simply deleted his @Ald4_WillBurns Twitter account. His Facebook page is still active, but his most recent posts are auto-shares of his newsletter, the latest of which has a simple copy and paste of a press release from the Mayor’s office detailing how his replacement will be found. No personal note. Burns' final appearance as alderman in the Council Chambers was before the Zoning Committee last week, to advocate for a new billboard that seven residents signed up to oppose.

His only formal press statement announcing his departure was on February 1st, a paragraph outlining some of his legislative accomplishments: new housing, retail, improved infrastructure, job creation, a higher minimum wage, and making neighborhoods the mid-South Side and South Loop safe and walkable. It ended, “I can look back at the last five years and see the change that we have created together, and I believe that our momentum will continue in the future.”

Few believe this marks Burns’ permanent exit from elected office, and several alluded to that fact during his official goodbye at the full City Council meeting last month, which was overshadowed by a debate over changes made to an Inspector General oversight ordinance and President Obama’s visit to Springfield. “You will come back to public life because it’s part of your calling,” Mayor Emanuel told him.

While many aldermen were surprised at the timing of Burns’ announcement, a few said privately that Burns didn’t have much of a taste for the job. During their goodbyes, some aldermen joked that they often disagreed with him, but knew they’d see him in 366 days, referring to the city’s revolving door restrictions.

“I think you’re going to be a millionaire,” Ald. Pat Dowell (3), Burns’ neighbor said, to laughs, “Don’t forget your friends.”

“It’s not over,” Ald. Walter Burnett (27) said of Burns’ political career during his goodbye on the council floor. “Will and I spar sometimes in the boxing ring. Will can take a punch and Will can give a punch… He never gives up, he bobs and weaves, and he makes things happen. I look forward to sparring with you in the future.”

Ald. Ed Burke said of his in his 47 years in City Council that Burns was “one of the best.”

Burke will soon know if Burns’ replacement will be one of the best: the search committee tasked with finding the new Fourth Ward alderman must submit their top three picks to Mayor Emanuel by this Friday.

Ald. Michelle Harris (8) raised more money than anyone else on the City Council in February, adding roughly $166k to her personal campaign fund as she runs for Clerk for the Circuit Court of Cook County. Ald. Brendan Reilly (42) trailed far behind in second place, reporting about $27K in new money over the same period. Meanwhile, two aldermen received donations from a construction company that has been doing business with the city since 2001, and one alderman reported a $50k donation from one individual, which is significantly higher than the $5.4K cap imposed on individual contributions to personal campaign funds.

Notable Individual Contributions:

• Ald. Carrie Austin (34) reported a $50k contribution from Patrick Heneghan, a business litigation partner at the law firm of Schopf & Weiss, LLP. That amount is well beyond the $5.4k cap imposed on individual contributions to personal campaign funds. (Aldertrack called Ald. Austin’s office to determine if the amount is a typo, but they did not confirm with us by publication deadline.)

• Ald. Austin also got a $1K donation from Ald. Ed Burke’s Burnham Committee. In January, Ald. Austin joined Burke in using a parliamentary procedure to delay a vote by the City Council on plan to put the city’s Inspector General Joe Ferguson in charge of investigating aldermen. That move gave them enough time push a diluted version of the ordinance through the council.  

• Custom Strains, a medical marijuana dispensary that got approval from the Zoning Board of Appeals in November to open a dispensary in the 28th Ward, donated $3k to Ald. Jason Ervin (28). ZBA had previously approved a special use permit for Custom Strains to open a dispensary in Fulton Market (1105 W. Fulton Market St.), but according to the company’s attorney, Jim Banks, who spoke at the November ZBA meeting, unnamed “obstacles” at that site proved too difficult to allow the project to proceed. Instead, his clients found another site: an old car dealership at 1301 S. Western Ave, located within a few blocks from the Illinois Medical District, Garfield Park, and the Union Pacific Railyard. Ald. Ervin spoke in favor of the dispensary at that ZBA hearing, noting its close location to area hospitals and the applicant’s commitment to refurbish a building that had been vacant for over five years.

• Benchmark Construction, a building company that does business with the city, gave money to two aldermen: $2.5k to Ald. Deb Mell (33) and $1k to Ald. Roderick Sawyer (6). In 2014, the company won a $11.2M city contract the 37th Street Sewer Improvement Project, among more than 40 other city construction contracts dating back to 2001.

• The Magellan Development Group, the real estate firm behind the famed Wanda Vista project, donated $2.5K to Ald. Brendan Reilly’s (42) personal campaign fund. The Plan Commission and the Council recently approved a planned development for the “supertall” downtown lakefront skyscraper that will consist of four interconnected, all glass, curve-shaped buildings, each one taller than the next. David Carlins, a developer with Magellan, also donated $2.5k to Ald. Reilly.

• Fred Eychaner, owner of Newsweb Corporation, a Chicago-based company that owns several ethnic and alternative newspapers, gave money to two Aldermen, Deb Mell and Scott Waguespack (32). His $1K and $1.5K contribution to them, respectively, dwarfs the $400K he gave to Cook County State’s Attorney candidate Kim Foxx in February.

• The Peter Kamberos Revocable Trust donated $2.5k to Ald. James Cappleman (46). Kamberos is the husband of Cook County Treasurer Maria Pappas.

• Kimbal Goluska, president of the Chicago Consultants Studio, Inc. and a board member of the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce donated $5,000 to the 4th Ward Democratic Organization. She is a proponent of opening a casino in downtown Chicago.

Biggest Fundraisers:

• Ald. Michelle Harris (8), who is running for Clerk for the Circuit Court of Cook, raised more money than anyone else on the City Council in February, adding roughly $166k to her newly-created personal campaign fund, Citizens for Michelle Harris. But that number isn’t truly representative of how much cash she brought in for the month of February, since it includes a $48K transfer from her other, older campaign fund, Friends of Michelle Harris, which is still active. That fund closed out the the fourth quarter of 2015 with about $228,600 in the bank, and received only one contribution in February: a $2.5K transfer from Ald. Will Burns (4). Meanwhile, Ald. Harris’ new fund reeled in some sizable checks from MWRD Commissioner Marty Durkan ($50k), the Construction & General Laborers’ District Council of Chicago ($10K), and Grosvenor Capital Management($25K). The Durkan transfer helped pay for these double sided mailers blasting Gov. Rauner.

• Ald. Brendan Reilly (42) was the second highest fundraiser on the City Council for the month of February, reeling in about $27K in political contributions. The largest check came from Michael Bisbee, Owner of LGN Group. He also got a $3.5K contribution from Bill Gritsonis, a consultant with PCG Consulting, Inc., a management consulting firm based in Boston, MA, “that serves primarily public sector education, health and human services agencies, and other state, county, and municipal government clients.” Ald. Reilly also transferred $15k from his personal campaign fund (Citizens for Alderman Reilly) to the 42nd Ward Democratic Organization, which he also controls as 42nd Ward Democratic Committeeman.

• In addition to receiving money from Benchmark Construction, Ald. Sawyer reported campaign donations from the Illinois Hotel-Motel Political Action Committee($1K); Unison Consulting, a Chicago-based, “leading aviation consulting firm” that is certified as a minority and disadvantaged business, according the the company’s website ($1K); Nikki Zollar, a member of the board of trustees for Chicago State University ($1.7K); and Killerspin, LLC, a table tennis facility ($1K).

• Ald. Scott Waguespack (32) reported five $1K contribution checks from Baker Development Corporation, the real estate firm that oversaw the development of the 180,000-square-foot big box retail complex located on the border of Lincoln Park and Bucktown. It’s directly across the Chicago River from the Lathrop Homes, a public housing complex that will soon become a massive mixed-used development once the City Council approves the master plan for the site. That Lathrop plan calls for 50,000-square-feet of commercial retail, which Ald. Waguespack opposes because there’s no shortage of retail space in the area, his Chief of Staff Paul Sajovec told the Plan Commission. Two of those checks Ald. Waguespack reported list a different limited liability corporation (2230 Elston, LLC; Baker Lincoln, LLC) with the same address: 1156 W. Armitage Ave., the headquarters for Baker Development.  Checks from 105 Madison OPCO, Inc. and W & A Baker Building Trust list the same address as the two LLCs. One check from Elston Development, LLC lists a separate address on the SBOE website, but according to state records, the LLC is owned by Baker Development, too. Ald. Waguespack also got $1k from Midtown Athletic and $2.5k from Steven Schwartz, owner of the Midtown Athletic Club.

• IL State Sen. Tony Munoz’s 12th Ward Regular Democratic Organization raised $12k in February. MWRD Commissioner Michael Alvarez donated $1k and Cook County Democratic Party Chairman and Assessor Joe Berrios gave $1k. Meanwhile, Friends of Twelve, the PAC run by Ald. George Cardenas (12), who is running against Munoz for 12th Ward Democratic Committeeman, reported one contribution: a $11.3K check from All Around Amusements, a carnival company located in Lockport, IL. Ald. Cardenas’ personal campaign fund received four checks totaling $8K. The largest donation, $5K, came from Theresa Siaw from Burr Ridge, IL. Siaw’s occupation is listed as “Healthcare.” Her LinkedIn says she’s a Board Member for Centro Romero, a “community-based organization that served the refugee immigrant population on the northeast side of Chicago,” according to its website.

• Ald. Pat Dowell got a notable amount of political support: $5k from State Rep. Mattie Hunter, $3K from State Rep. Lou Lang, $2K from Mike Zalewski (she didn’t specify if the check came from Ald. Zalewski or his son, the state rep. who shares his name), $1.5k from State Rep. Marcus C. Evans, Jr., $1.5k from State Rep. Bob Rita; and $1.5k from State Rep. Silvana Tabares.

• Ald. Raymond Lopez (15) received $2K from Gutierrez for Congress, the personal campaign fund for U.S. Cong. Luis Gutierrez. The two were seen together at a campaign event for Theresa Mah, whom both are supporting in the upcoming election against incumbent State Rep. Alex Acevedo.

• Ald. Chris Taliaferro (29) got some political support, too, with $5K from Ald. Nick Sposato (38) and $2K from Cook County Commissioner Richard Boykin.

• City Treasurer Kurt Summers raised $19,700 in February, including three $5.4K checks from Chicago-based investment firm Victory Capital Advisors, the company’s partner and co-founder Brendan Carroll, and his wife, Colleen Carroll, who is listed as a “homemaker.”

• “The Democratic Party of the 49th Ward,” the political party campaign fund for the 49th Ward Democratic Ward Organization, has beefed up its fundraising efforts since Ald. Joe Moore took over as ward committeeman following David Fagus’death last year. The campaign fund reported $17K in new contributions in February, including $5K from State Sen. Heather Steans; $1K from the law firm DLA Piper; $1.5K from JN Pritzker; and $2.5K from Azieb Gebrehiiwet, a day care provider who got an honorary street designation from the City in 2014.

• The 28th Ward Democratic Organization run by Ald. Jason Ervin (28) received $16k in February, all of which came from construction companies.  

Non-Financial Highlights:

• The treasurer for Ald. Scott Waguespack’s personal campaign committee, Angelina Briguglio, resigned in January, according to this letter filed on Feb. 25th with the SBOE.

• Ald. Ervin (28) created a new campaign, “Ervin for Committeeman” on Feb 10. But despite the name, the campaign fund won’t be fundraising for Ald. Ervin’s re-election campaign for Democratic ward committeeman, instead, it will support the campaign of his wife, Melissa Conyears-Ervin, a candidate for state rep.

Protesters call B.S. and disrupt the Mayor's final Police Accountability Task Force meeting, shutting it down two hours early. The Mayor's tobacco ordinance is stalled, and now the two sides of the debate–health versus higher taxes–duke it out. And a new charter school gets the zoning change it wants... even though it hurt one alderman's feelings.

A day-long hearing on Ald. Joe Moreno's Chicago Housing Authority reform ordinance puts public housing in the spotlight, with CHA fans saying the agency's new head, Eugene Jones, is making good progress, while critics say the agency is stockpiling cash instead of building affordable units. Meanwhile, CHA and a team of developers push a master plan for the long-awaited Lathrop Homes redevelopment on the Northwest Side through Plan Commission. Down in Springfield, Gov. Bruce Rauner used his 2016 budget address to again, harp on financial woes at the Chicago Public Schools.

A pared-down ordinance giving the Inspector General oversight of City Council passes by a thin margin, while a hike in cigarette taxes and a hearing on a one shot cash infusion to CPS get tangled up by procedural maneuvers. Plus, aldermen sing Kumbaya and say goodbye to Ald. Will Burns (4), who is leaving City Hall to work for Airbnb.

Nothing Comes Easy Any More: Council Votes Delayed, Deferred and Failed
by Claudia Morell – [email protected]

Yesterday’s Council meeting started with almost two hours of resolutions of praise: with a tribute to Rev. Clay Evans, praise for Marine Corps veterans, a celebration of Chinese New Year and Black History Month. Following the conclusion of regular business, aldermen took some time to say goodbye to Ald. Will Burns (4), who announced his resignation last week, although most highlighted how much they enjoyed him, despite rarely agreeing with him.

While the meeting started with platitudes and congratulations, the Chamber was infused with tension, as a number of important votes either failed, were delayed through parliamentary maneuvering or were closer than expected:

• Mayor Rahm Emanuel's tobacco ordinance failed to clear Council yesterday, despite last-minute concessions made to aldermen concerned about the black market of loose cigarette sales;
• Ald. Michele Smith (43) and Ald. Ameya Pawar (47) took a hit yesterday, as well, with 29 of their colleagues voting to support a diluted version of their ethics reform plan to put the Inspector General in charge of policing aldermen;
• Finance Committee Chair Ed Burke at the last minute held from consideration a $200 million water bond authorization that would pay for previous “toxic swap” deals;

Aldermen say the phone lines were burning up last night, as Council members and Mayoral staff whipped votes on three contentious issues due for a vote this morning: acceptance of the O’Connor Working Group’s Inspector General substitute ordinance; passage of Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s proposed tobacco tax that was delayed from Monday to a special Finance Committee meeting called for 9:15 a.m.; and a previously tabled $200 million bond issuance to pay for swap termination fees.

Two sources last night counted 25 “no” votes for the IG substitute, but as the night wore on, one source said some of those “no” votes may be wavering.

Ald. Ameya Pawar (47) a co-sponsor of the original ordinance merging the Legislative Inspector General’s office with the City’s Inspector General’s Office, told Aldertrack yesterday afternoon that while the working group ordinance was still a work in progress and he believes the one he crafted with Ald. Michele Smith (42) is “the right ordinance,” he’s content IG Joe Ferguson will be empowered to oversee City Council after two years fighting for reform. “You don’t want the perfect to be the enemy of the good,” he said.

Per Rule 41, 26 votes are needed to discharge Pawar’s original ordinance to the floor. A substitution or amendment, like the working group’s proposed changes, can be introduced at that time as well, Pawar says. It will come down to a simple up or down vote during the “Unfinished Business” portion of the meeting.

The Council’s Finance Committee is also meeting this morning, an hour before the full City Council meeting, to vote on Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s proposal to raise the city’s smoking age to 21 and increase taxes on tobacco-related products. On Monday, a marathon-long hearing on the ordinance revealed that a significant number of aldermen oppose the plan for fear of how it will impact local businesses and crime.

Aldermen who represent wards along the city’s borders had expressed worry that the changes would drive out business to the surrounding suburbs and Indiana, where smoking products are cheaper. Others, predominantly from the city’s South and West Side, had expressed concern the high price of cigarette packs would fuel what they described to be a “booming” underground market of loose cigarette sales.

Members of the City Council’s Progressive Caucus don’t like the ordinance either, because the $6 million in expected revenue from the new tax would go to a CPS-run summer orientation program for new high school freshman, instead of anti-smoking programs. Ald. Scott Waguespack (32) said he would prefer the money pay for anti-smoking programs in elementary schools. It’s possible, one source said, a substitute may be introduced today that would divert some of those funds to smoking cessation programs so the Mayor will have enough votes to pass the ordinance.

Items Awaiting Council Approval Today (Highlights)

• 
  

  Legal Settlements: A $3.1M settlement with the U.S. DoJ over a hiring practice no longer in use that allegedly discriminated against foreign-born candidates. Ald. Nick Sposato (38) voted against it in committee. Also up: a $220,000 settlement with Tiffany Hondras, who filed a lawsuit against the police department alleging unlawful search and seizure, and a $200,000 settlement toJonathan and Jesse Hadnott, Kevin Hunt and Brandell Betts, who filed a joint lawsuit against the police department also alleging unlawful search and seizure.

  
  


• 
  

  Bond Offering: The Second Lien Water Revenue Project and Refunding Bonds, Series 2016a ($200M) are listed on the Finance Committee’s list of ordinances awaiting a vote, but according to Ald. Scott Waguespack (32), it’s supposed to be held for another month. Chairman Ed Burke (14) tabled the bond deal at last month’s City Council meeting after the Progressive Caucus pushed back, because it would pay for swap termination fees on existing debt. The PC wants to sue the banks instead. An ordinance calling for legal action against banks just got re-referred from the Budget Committee to the Finance Committee yesterday.

  
  


• 
  

  Zoning Changes for the old Malcolm X City College campus for the newBlackhawks ice rink and Rush University Medical Center academic campus.

  
  


• 
  

  Fee Waivers for all city permits and public way use permits for the Metropolitan Pier and Exposition Authority

  
  


• 
  

  Anti-Discrimination Protections for vets as it relates to finding and securing housing in Chicago. This ordinance also provides anti-retaliation measures to protect tenants who file complaints against their landlords.

  
  


• 
  

  Sale Of City-Owned Land for $1 to the University of Chicago for a new campus for their existing Woodlawn Charter School. Ald. Sue Sadlowski-Garza (10) and Ald. David Moore (17) voted against it in committee.

  
  


• 
  

  The BACP Top Cabbie Award Ordinance: sponsored by Mayor Emanuel, would create an incentive program to find “Chicago’s Top Cabbie”. Top prize is a free taxicab medallion.

  
  


• 
  

  Mobile Food Vendor Restrictions for Lincoln Park to restrict food cart vendors on nine separate stretches of restaurant-heavy sidewalks, including roughly quarter-mile spans of Armitage, Lincoln, Clark, Fullerton, and Halsted.

  
  


• 
  

  Expenditure of Open Space Impact Fee fund for Julia Burgos Park: The Logan Square Park would receive $235,000 in “Open Space Impact Fees,” which are taken from new residential developments to help expand and improve local park space. The money would help pay for environmental remediation costs at an adjacent vacant plot of land the city acquired.

  
  


• 
  

  TIF Money For Belmont Cragin Elementary School: transfers $287,000 in TIF funds for the construction of a new playground with rubber surfacing.

  
  


• 
  

  Changes To The City’s Procurement Goals For M/WBE Businesses: Would increase all city-funded contract goals from 24% to 26% for minority businesses and from 4% to 6% for women owned businesses. The ordinance originally called for 30% and 10%, respectively.

  
  


• 
  

  Divvy Expansion To Evanston And Oak Park: includes revenue sharing with Chicago. The City will pass through $320,000 to Evanston and $480,000 to Oak Park. Evanston will pay $80,000 in local matching funds, Oak Park will pay $120,000. Costs and revenues will be shared

  
  

Appointments

• 
  

  Julio Rodriguez as a member of the Commission on Human Relations; Reappointment of Naderh H. Elrabadi, Stephanie A. Kanter, David J. Mussatt, and Nabeela Rasheed as members of Chicago Commission on Human Relations.

  
  


• Designation of of Blake P. Sercye as Chairman of the Zoning Board of Appeals. The former chairman, Jonathan Swain, took a position on the Chicago Board of Elections. Sercye has been on ZBA for only a few months. Swain replaced Langdon Neal on the three-member board of commissioners.

Expected Intros: Ald. Moreno Demands Hearing on Prop. Tax Relief Plan, Hopkins Wants Legacy Buildings Protected

Ald. Joe Moreno (1) will be introducing a resolution demanding a hearing on an ordinance he introduced in September that would provide property tax relief to some homeowners whose homes are valued at $250,000 or less. The ordinance was introduced last fall in response to the Mayor’s historic property tax hike. “This [property tax increase] was approved with the caveat that the City would consider a citywide rebate program, if the state could not provide relief. As of this date, state action to provide relief to low- and middle-income homeowners has been stalled,” Ald. Moreno said in a release.

Moreno’s rebate plan is intended for households earning less than $100,000 a year. Homeowners would apply for the program with the Department of Finance, and the City’s Chief Financial Officer would establish and administer it. The CFO could call on the Office of Compliance to conduct eligibility audits.

Read the formula with an example here.

The dollar amount homeowners would get back is multiplied by the difference in the City’s real estate tax assessment rate from last year to this year, then multiplied by the equalized assessed value of the home. Which basically means a home with $50,000 a year in income worth $250,000 could be eligible for a rebate just over $208, delivered by check. The Chicago Tribune estimates that if Emanuel’s proposed increases were in effect this year, the total bill on a $250,000 home would go up by $342, to $4,504. About 270,000 Chicago households would be eligible to apply for Moreno’s program.

According to Ald. Moreno’s count, there are six co-sponsors: Ald. Pat Dowell (3), Ald. Roderick Sawyer (6), Ald. Michael Scott, Jr. (24), Ald. Danny Solis (25), Ald. Ariel Reboyras (30), and Ald. Joe Moore (49).

Ald Brian Hopkins (2) also plans to introduce an ordinance that will “allow any Alderman or the Mayor to nominate a longstanding business deemed an economic or cultural fixture to the community for at least 30 years,” to become a so-called “Legacy Business.” The designation is aimed in part to help longstanding businesses survive rising property tax rates.

Up to 300 legacy businesses could be nominated per year. A business has to have operated in Chicago for at least 30 years, contributed to the neighborhood's history or identity, and committed to maintaining its, “physical features or traditions that define the business.” To be included on DPD's list, businesses would pay a $50 administrative fee. Those fees and across the board business licensing fee hikes (most by $5), would help fund the program.

Legacy Businesses could apply for a special grant from DPD awarding $500 per full-time equivalent employee. Landlords with 10+ year lease agreements with Legacy Businesses could also apply for a grant, at $4.50 per square foot, maxing out at 5,000 square feet per location.

Ald. Gilbert Villegas (36) says he is forming a new City Council Veteran Caucus withAld. Ed Burke (14), Ald. George Cardenas (12), Ald. Danny Solis (25), Ald. Milly Santiago (31), and Ald. Chris Taliaferro (29). And they’re set to meet officially for the first time this morning.

“The Mayor has a new director of Veterans Affairs,” Villegas told Aldertrack. “We want to make sure he has the resources he needs to be successful, and to introduce legislation to benefit veterans.” The current Acting Chair of the Mayor’s 21-memberAdvisory Council on Veterans Affairs is Victor Lagroon, first appointed to the board in 2012.

Veterans' issues have popped up in City Council twice in as many weeks. Former 11th Ward Ald. James Balcer stopped by the Council Monday during the discussion of the Mayor’s proposed tobacco tax and hike in the smoking age. Balcer told aldermen vets and active military personnel should be exempt from the age restrictions. He argued that if vets are old enough to fight for their country and vote, they’re old enough to smoke.

And last week, the Committee on Human Relations advanced an ordinance that would make it harder for landlords to discriminate against veteran and active duty military personnel looking for housing.

Ald. Taliaferro, a Marine Corps veteran, confirmed he’d be joining the caucus, but said he couldn’t speak on a new veterans affairs head.

As a caucus member, he said he’d look for opportunities for veterans when they return from military service, including increasing access to existing help. “Many of the veterans that I’ve spoken with are not aware of the benefits that they have available through VA.”

For the second time in a month, a widely-sponsored City Council ordinance was derailed by Budget Chair Carrie Austin. Yesterday, Austin, one of Council’s most senior members, delayed a hearing on a TIF surplus resolution from Ald. Carlos Ramirez-Rosa (35), a freshman alderman, by at least a month. The resolution “calls for immediate TIF surplus action to offset drastic cuts at our Chicago Public Schools.”

In a quick motion, Austin referred it to the Finance Committee without asking whether there were any objections.

After the committee voted on item three, Austin went out of agenda order. “Items six and seven will be re-referred to the Committee on Finance.” Moving back to item four, and skipping the usual “Hearing no objection, so ordered.”

In fact, Ald. Ricardo Munoz (22) was vocally objecting, and asking for a roll call on the motion to re-refer. “Madame Chair, Madame Chair,” he repeated loudly, but Austin moved past his objection to an item on M/WBE procurement.

“Ald. Munoz, I’ll recognize you when I have the procurement director speaking on this matter,” she told him. The committee then spent roughly 15 minutes discussing M/WBE changes, until Ald. Austin called on Munoz again.

He asked for a roll call on the motion to re-refer to Finance, saying he had objected.

“I believe that the rule of the Chair stands,” Austin told him, “Ald. [Ed] Burke [Chair of the Finance Committee] has re-referred items and there was no vote, so my assumption…” Munoz interrupted to say that he had vocally objected.

Off mic, Ald. Anthony Beale (9) said he wanted to table the roll call, which Munoz said didn’t qualify for tabling.

At that point, demonstrators, including some parents associated with Raise Your Hand, who about an hour earlier had held a press conference in support of Ald. Rosa’s resolution, stood along the partition separating the Council floor from the gallery, chanting, “Parents want a voice,” and “Parents want a vote.” Austin and Munoz continued to go back and forth above the din.

Austin banged her gavel multiple times, trying to speak above protestors, and saying she couldn’t hear. “The parents don’t run this committee,” she said. There was, despite Munoz’s objection, a roll call to table Munoz’s motion. Austin’s aide reported 10 ayes and 8 nays aloud. The Clerk’s office doesn’t track committee votes, and aides for Austin did not respond to a request for a roll call breakdown. DNA Info reported 10 ayes and 9 nays:

Yea: Chair Carrie Austin (34), Brian Hopkins (2), Pat Dowell (3), Anthony Beale (9), Derrick Curtis (18), Willie Cochran (20), Jason Ervin (28), Emma Mitts (37), Margaret Laurino (39) and Joe Moore (49)

Nay: Ald. Roderick Sawyer (6), Marty Quinn (13), Rick Munoz (22), Ariel Reboyras (30), Scott Waguespack (32), Deb Mell (33), Brendan Reilly (42), Tom Tunney (44), Deb Silverstein (50)

City CFO Alex Holt and budget staffer Molly Poppe were in the Chambers and prepared to testify, distributing a memo saying if aldermen wanted to expire a TIF, the Mayor’s Office would give up the city’s 18% cut to CPS. Poppe said she did not believe there would be a vote, but that there would be testimony.

One of Austin’s staffers later handed out photocopy of a paragraph in city’s municipal code that says the Finance Committee is the appropriate jurisdiction to hear all tax-related matters. The full City Council today will get to vote on whether to approve Austin’s re-referral to the Finance Committee, where its fate, so far, is uncertain.

At meeting’s end, reporters swarmed Chair Austin, who at first, would only take questions about the M/WBE ordinance. She pushed away a recorder placed too closely on the desk in front of her. Aides removed files, pencils, pens, and her bejeweled thermos while she took more than 15 minutes worth of questions.

Asked for a response to Ald. Rosa’s accusation that the referral was an old-school stalling tactic, “I don’t know what that means,” Austin replied. “When I say something in my committee, it is not to be at somebody else. I sent it to Finance where it belongs… now if he’s objecting to that, I’m sorry… Anything with TIFs, it’s Finance’s deal. He thinks that it’s something against him, it’s not. He thinks that it’s something against our children, no it’s not! I’m sending it to its proper committee.”

Munoz disagreed. “Both committees have jurisdiction over TIF surplus and TIF expenditures. The bottom line is the City Council Committee on Budget and Government Operations put it on their agenda for a public hearing. The public hearing should have been had.”

As for the immediate impact on CPS, Munoz said, “They need money as soon as possible. It’s evident,” and he doesn’t want to wait another month to see further cuts. Hours later, CPS announced it would reduce school budgets by another $120 million.

Ald. Beale said his move wasn’t politically motivated, but procedural. “We followed the proper procedures for where it was supposed to be, other than sitting here trying to grandstand on something… you know. So that’s all we did… they sent it to the wrong committee.”

Beale says there are three TIFs within his ward, including the partially TIF-fundedPullman Park redevelopment project. A freshman alderman shouldn’t be telling him what to do with it, even if he has 34 co-sponsors, declared Beale.

“It’s dead on arrival,” he said twice. “I have the largest development in the City of Chicago going on right now. I’m not going to let somebody tell me what’s best for my community when I’m creating thousands of jobs, reducing crime because those jobs are being created. Now you just want to take people’s TIFs for a one shot, shot in the arm to do what? Learn the job before you start dictating what other aldermen should be doing with their TIF money.”

Rosa reiterated that the Mayor’s office led him to believe the resolution was in the right committee, and Budget Director Alex Holt’s testimony would have cleared up Beale’s issues. Rosa said the resolution was a starting point, and he wouldn't force aldermen to halt their TIF projects.

Rosa and Ald. Ameya Pawar (47) both doubled down on commitments to explore expiring TIFs in their own wards and redirecting the surplus money toward CPS.

Expiring a TIF before its expiration date requires City Council approval. Obligations for the TIF must be paid off, and tax districts who get TIF money are notified, but don’t hold any legal authority to formally object. In her memo to aldermen today, Holt said she would be happy to work with aldermen who want to freeze or terminate TIF districts in their ward, but “it’s a balancing act,” she told Aldertrack. “In order to generate much in the way of surplus, we have to talk about canceling projects, that’s something that aldermen say they have to prefer to surplus money instead of spending it on a park or school annex.”

Other Budget Committee Actions

A Progressive Caucus ordinance aimed at recouping losses from swap deals with banks was also re-referred to Finance Committee by Chairman Austin. The ordinance directs the Department of Law to explore legal action concerning early termination penalties, recovering past losses and repayment on all interest rate swap agreements.

The committee approved an amendment to the municipal code continuing the MBE/WBE Construction Procurement Program. Last month, Budget Chair Carrie Austin called for a temporary extension of the city’s Minority and Women-Owned Business Construction Program that was set to expire at the end of the year. Yesterday, Jamie Rhee, the city's Chief Procurement Officer, said the Mayor’s office wanted to increase all city-funded contract goals from 24% to 26% for minority businesses and from 4% to 6% for women owned businesses. The ordinance originally called for 30% and 10%.

Rhee said she believed the lower figures could be defended in court. The program will last five years, and there will be an interim review at the end of 2017 to assess whether the targets are appropriate.

Ald. Gilbert Villegas (36), who pushed for the 30-10 goals, congratulated Austin on the changes, which he said the city could work to incrementally increase. “I know this is something that your husband [Ald. Lemuel Austin] worked on during the Harold Washington days,” he told the chair, and said he wants to continue pushing for local hiring.

After more than two hours of testimony, close to two dozen public witnesses, one room change, and one mid-meeting closed door session, the Council’s Zoning Committee approved a zoning change for the controversial Montrose Clarendon project at the site of the former Maryville/Cueno Hospital in the city’s Uptown neighborhood.

Members Present (10/17): Chairman Danny Solis (25), Vice Chairman James Cappleman (46),  Ald. Joe Moreno (1), Ald. Toni Foulkes (16), Ald. Matt O’Shea (19), Ald. Walter Burnett, Jr. (27), Ald. Deb Mell (33), Ald. Emma Mitts (38), Ald. Brendan Reilly (42), Tom Tunney (44).

The project took up the bulk of the four hour zoning meeting as residents, one-by-one, provided testimony on a zoning change that would facilitate construction of a massive housing complex with 631 units at the nearly 5-acre shuttered hospital campus.

Opponents said the Cueno Hospital buildings should be designated as landmarks, not torn down. Several lamented a $15.8 million TIF subsidy that was made available to the project, and a few demanded more affordable housing units on site. The community of homeless people living under a nearby viaduct was brought up several times as a point of outrage.

Proponents said they’re glad to finally see the site, which has been vacant for years, turned into something new. Several community leaders argued this proposal was the product of years of negotiations with the developers and touted the economic impact to the neighborhood.

At one point, after getting into a few back-and-forth arguments with residents over what is legally required as it pertains to TIF money and affordable housing, local Alderman and Committee Vice Chairman James Cappleman (46) asked that Zoning Administrator Patti Scudiero step in and explain the zoning code.

When it was finally his turn to testify, Ald. Cappleman detailed his involvement in the project, from his first month in office to yesterday’s meeting. To address the housing disparity charges raised, he said the project passed through several local community meetings, “and reflected the economic diversity of the 46th Ward.” On the TIF issue, he said the land is currently tax exempt (it was a hospital site), which means it won’t generate any money until something is built there. The new project will generate $2 to $3 million a year in property taxes, according to his count.

“Without this project our community will continue to have a boarded up, vacant building that brings more crime to this neighborhood that is already incredibly overburdened,” he concluded, somewhat shouting by this point.

Following the public comment portion, Chairman Solis called for a five minute recess for aldermen to talk privately to DPD staff. When he returned, he immediately called the item up for consideration by voice vote. “Call the roll,” people in the gallery chanted as aldermen cast their vote in unison. It was divided with a few audible “nays.”

“This is democracy in Chicago,” one person in the gallery yelled.

Ald. Joe Moreno (1), who has recently made affordable housing a soapbox issue, accused the developer's lawyer, Mariah DiGrino with DLA Piper, of being “disingenuous” when she suggested the project “exceeded” the city’s 2007 ARO.

The joint venture by JDL Development and Harlem Irving Companies would cost $125 million and will be supported with $15.8 million in TIF assistance. 20 units, about 5% of total units, will be made affordable. The developer will also make two large cash payments totaling about $8 million to the city’s affordable housing trust fund to make up for the remaining affordable units required under the city’s 2007 affordable requirements ordinance.

The apartments would be divided between two high rise buildings. One building to be located at the northwest corner of West Montrose and North Clarendon Avenue would have 381 residential units. The other, at the northwest corner of West Agatite and North Clarendon Avenues, would hold 250 residential units. Other amenities in the new planned development would include a third single-story structure (a grocery store) at the corner of West Montrose and North Clarendon Avenues.

Other Applications

The Montrose-Clarendon project was the only item on the agenda to receive significant pushback. A couple of residents from the 4th Ward testified against an “off premise sign” at 600 S. Clark Street in the city’s Printer’s Row neighborhood.

The billboard would be too big (14 by 48 feet) and doesn’t conform with the surrounding neighborhood, said Chuck Gullett, a resident at a 60-unit condo building “catty-corner” to the location of the proposed sign. He and another resident said they were just notified about the hearing yesterday and requested that the item be held.

Chairman Danny Solis requested someone from the 4th Ward speak, but no one was present, so Ald. Brendan Reilly (42) suggested the item be held or voted down because, “the Fourth Ward has no alderman.” Ald. Will Burns (4) announced last week that he will be stepping down from his post. He’s accepting a job at Airbnb.

Ald. Joe Moreno (1) chimed in to say, “The Fourth Ward has an alderman, he’s just not here now,” and suggested the item be held. Chairman Solis held the item so the residents could work the issue out with Ald. Burns.

No one from the public (save for perennial speaker George Blakemore) testified on other proposed plans. All were approved unanimously by voice vote:

• 
  

  Landmark Status for the Marina City Towers: The committee swiftly approved landmark designation for the twin, 60-story corncob-shaped residential high-rises in the Loop. According to Ned Crawford with the city’s Landmarks Commission, the two Marina City Towers are icons because the building, often called “a city within a city,” was the the “first of its kind to layer residential, commercial, and entertainment uses into a dense high-rise complex in the city’s center.” Local Ald. Brendan Reilly (42) called the designation “long overdue.” The Commission on Chicago Landmarks made their preliminary recommendation to designate the two buildings as official landmarks in November.

  
  


• 
  

  Milwaukee TOD Gets one ‘No’ Vote: Ald. Joe Moreno voted against Vequity’s application for a zoning change to construct a six-story, 44-unit luxury high rise along a heavily trafficked intersection on Milwaukee Avenue (1920 N. Milwaukee Ave.) Moreno voted against the project because no affordable housing was provided on site. Instead, the developers will be making a cash payment to the city’s affordable housing trust fund.

  
  


• 
  

  Event Liquor Licenses: An ordinance that establishes an industrial private event license for large warehouses located in four PMDs (planned manufacturing districts) got approval from the committee. It was sponsored by Zoning Chairman Solis. According to Buildings Commissioner Judy Frydland, who testified on the ordinance because she helped draft it when she worked for the city’s Law Department, the new license would be limited to private events, such as weddings, fundraisers, corporate parties and those not open to the general public.
  
  The warehouse would have to be a minimum of 15,000 square feet. Alcohol would be allowed on site, insurance would be required, and a licensee would have to develop an on-site safety plan and give notice to local businesses. Chairman Solis said the ordinance would provide much needed revenue to the city, in addition to “protecting” these districts and providing a regulatory framework to keep track of these kinds of parties. Ald. Reilly voiced concern the license would lead to a lot of raves. Chairman Solis said provisions in the ordinance would prevent that. Pop-up establishments are not allowed.
  
  Giving the issues some context, Ald. Walter Burnett, Jr. (27) pointed to a recent incident where Mercedes Benz held a party in their Fulton Marketwarehouse and attendees clogged the streets with their cars, making it impossible for local residents to find parking. This ordinance would prevent incidents like that from happening because the surrounding community would be given the opportunity to object to the license.

  
  

The City Council Budget Committee meets today at 10:00 a.m. to hear resolutions and ordinances that would direct the Law Department to fight against early termination penalties, possibly hike fees for building inspections done by the fire department, and encourage the city to re-route TIF surplus funds to help plug CPS’ budget gap. Specifically:

• 
  

  An ordinance directing the Department of Law to explore legal action concerning early termination penalties, recovering past losses and repayment on all interest rate swap agreements: This Progressive Caucusordinance argues the City and CPS have paid more than $1.1 billion in payments for interest rate swap deals and the city should work to recoup them. “Other public and private entities in the United States have taken legal action... and avoided or lowered termination penalties for interest rate swap agreements and were repaid payments previously made to financial institutions.” Progressive Caucus opposition to swap termination fees within a $200 million water revenue bond deal last month delayed the sale (for the time being).

  
  


• 
  

  TIF Surplus for CPS Resolution: More than half the City Council has signed on to the CPS-TIF Surplus resolution that Ald. Carlos Ramirez-Rosa (35) introduced last month. The resolution states the City Council would be in favor of “immediate new TIF surplus action, in addition to the surplus declared in August 2015, be utilized to mitigate any program cuts, layoffs of staff, and reductions in services in the Chicago Public Schools.” Diverting TIF surplus to schools, though it would fall short of CPS’ initial $480 million budget gap for this year, would “offset drastic cuts”, keep “essential programs”, and alleviate “potential mass layoffs. Legislation introduced in Springfield by Rep. Barbara Flynn Currie would divert all TIF surplus to CPS in this emergency situation instead of to other local taxing bodies. Aldermen will hold a press conference an hour before the meeting on the second floor of City Hall to highlight this item, which more than half of the city council has signed up to co-sponsor.

  
  


• 
  

  An intergovernmental agreement to expand Divvy to Evanston and Oak Park: Chicago has so far received $28 million from the federal government for the bike sharing program, with the city chipping in roughly $6.5 million. According to the IGA, the City will pass through $320,000 to Evanston and $480,000 to Oak Park for an “interoperable”, branded Divvy program. Evanston will pay $80,000 in local matching funds, Oak Park will pay $120,000. Costs and revenues will be shared: Chicago will get annual membership fees for people whose addresses are listed in Chicago and anywhere outside Evanston or Oak Park, and annual memberships purchased by people with Evanston or Oak Park mailing addresses will be distributed to each. Revenue from overage fees and 24-hour passes will also go towards the municipality where the ride originates.

  
  


• 
  

  An ordinance authorizing the fire commissioner to pick a program for electronic tracking and billing of building inspections: The ordinance authorizes Fire Commissioner Jose Santiago to choose a provider for electronic handling of inspection records and fees for those inspections. The costs will be borne by inspectors, who can pass on charges to building owners.

  
  


• A communication recommending a proposed ordinance amending the municipal code concerning the continuation of the MBE/WBE Construction Procurement Program: Last month, Budget Chair Carrie Austin called for a temporary extension of the city’s Minority and Women-Owned Business (M/WBE) Construction Program that was set to expire at the end of the year. The original ordinance extended it through 2020, but Austin called for temporary stretch through March 31, 2016. Since this is just a communication, the committee won’t hear testimony or debate changes to the M/WBE Construction Procurement Program at this meeting.

For more than three hours, aldermen from a broad spectrum of backgrounds pushed back against Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s proposed tobacco regulations that would increase the city’s smoking age to 21 and generate $6 million in new revenue from increased taxes on tobacco products. Committee Finance Chairman Ed Burkeeventually decided to hold the item for further consideration.

At the end of yesterday's meeting, Burke called a new meeting on Wednesday at 9:15 a.m. to reconsider the item.

Present: Chairman Ed Burke (14), Joe Moreno (1), Pat Dowell (3), Leslie Hairston (5), Roderick Sawyer (6) Greg Mitchell (7), Anthony Beale (9), Sue Sadlowski Garza (10),  Patrick Daley Thompson (11), Marty Quinn (13), Toni Foulkes (16), David Moore (17), Matt O’Shea (19), Willie Cochran (20), Howard Brookins, Jr. (21), Rick Munoz (22), Mike Zalewski (23), Michael Scott, Jr. (24), Danny Solis (25), Walter Burnett, Jr. (27), Jason Ervin (28), Carrie Austin (34), Marge Laurino (38), Scott Waguespack (32), Nick Sposato (38), Pat O’Connor (40), Tom Tunney (44), John Arena (45), James Cappleman (46), Ameya Pawar (47) Harry Osterman (48), Deb Silverstein (50)

Yesterday’s Finance Committee meeting started with a full press gallery, likely in anticipation of a debate on a resolution urging the city to quickly settle the a lawsuit filed by Bettie Ruth Jones, the woman accidentally killed by the Chicago police officer responding to the Quintonio Legrier call, but a section of the gallery emptied out moments after the meeting was called to order when Chairman Burke (14) announced that he and resolution sponsor Ald. Jason Ervin (28) agreed to hold the resolution and submit it to a subcommittee to fix the “verbiage.”

Tobacco Tax Debate

Expressing worry that the increased taxes would kill small businesses, especially those located in border wards, and fuel the underground market of loose cigarette sales, aldermen argued the new regulations would cause more harm than good during three hours of debate.

[Draft Substitute Ordinance Language]

While the revenue generated by the new tax would fund a new orientation program for CPS freshmen smoking cessation programs, some aldermen argued the enforcement mechanism is unclear; a few questioned whether the Department of Business Affairs and Consumer Protection (BACP) or the city’s police department would take over the reins to enforce the new rules.

Although Chicago’s cigarette tax is already the highest in the nation, Public Health Commissioner Julie Morita, M.D. says raising the tobacco age would to curb youth smoking at a key time when their brains are still developing. Smokers who start at a younger age will have a harder time quitting as they get older, she said. Young consumers are also more price sensitive.

But Ald. Leslie Hairston (5) rejected that premise, pointing to the thousands of young adults who buy expensive concert tickets, cell phones, and designer clothing and shoes. “It seems like we are a city that wants to chase people away,” she said, garnering cheers from the gallery.

South Side Ald. Roderick Sawyer (6) says he knows one man who makes $800 a day selling loose cigarettes. He gave voice to concerns that the new taxes would hurt “communities of color”. Ald. Jason Ervin (28) recalled a constituent who used to sell loose cigarettes out in the “freezing cold” but now sells those cigarettes “from the luxury of a brand new Jeep.”

When Commissioner Morita suggested aldermen were raising “theoretical” concerns about black market sales, Ald. Ervin shot back, “I would implore you to walk down Madison with me, from Hamlin all the way to Kosner, and you will see the real consequences of what we’re talking about. This is not theoretical. This is not something I dreamed up,” he added.

Apologizing and saying she misspoke when dismissing Ervin’s comments, Morita tried to shift the conversation back to the public health benefits of the ordinance.

But few aldermen were interested in talking about health. While they agreed curbing youth smoking is admirable, they said they couldn't understand why the city felt the need to target small business owners who, in some cases, could see up to a 50% reduction in sales.

Several aldermen asked to hear how CPS plans to spend the $6 million in potential new revenue. The Mayor’s office has said it would be earmarked for a new week-long orientation program for students entering their freshman year of high school. Finding it odd that the new taxes are aimed at curbing smoking, which theoretically would lead to a reduction in year-over-year revenue, Ald. Patrick Daley Thompson (11) asked how the summer program could continue when the annual revenue isn’t guaranteed. Morita said she didn’t have an answer.

Even former Ald. James Balcer (11) showed up to testify against the ordinance. Balcer, who is a veteran, said vets and active military personnel should be exempt from the age restrictions, because, as he put it, if they are old enough to fight for their country and vote, they are old enough to smoke.

As the hearing approached the three hour mark, Ald. Ameya Pawar (47), who is not a member of the committee, but is one of the ordinance's lead sponsors, had had enough and accused his colleagues of backing big tobacco.

“I’m at a loss, we have progressives saying they’re for tobacco. I don’t know what is going on when we have people carrying the water of tobacco companies,” he opined. Taking his comments a step further, Ald. Pawar said yesterday’s focus on the economic impact of tobacco sales was akin to colonial times, when during the British occupation of India, the British used to give out free cigarettes as a way “to get them hooked so they could pay for them later.”

The dividing issue of public health versus business interest carried over into the public portion of the meeting. Representatives from the American Heart Association and area hospitals lined up to support the ordinance for its health benefits.

Representatives from the Illinois Retail Merchants Association, 7-Eleven, Jewel Osco, and two South Side pastors testified against the ordinance, citing the economic burden they’d face and the potential legal issues the city would open itself up to if it approved the changes.

According to Tanya Triche, vice president and general counsel of the Illinois Retail Merchants Association (IRMA), Chicago has no jurisdiction to impose a new tax because the state legislature ended that authority in the early 1990s. Should the industry take legal action on this package, the recent taxes the City Council approved on vaping products could be folded into the lawsuit. “These are very murky legal waters,” she warned.

Committee Approves $3M+ In Police-Related Legal Settlements

The handful of aldermen who remained in the Council chambers following the heated debate on tobacco approved about $3.5 million in legal settlements lodged against the city’s police department. All three settlements were approved together by voice vote following testimony on each item from Jane Notz with the City’s Law Department.

The biggest amount, $3.1 million, settles a Department of Justice suit against a hiring practice no longer in effect that required ten-years continuous residency in the U.S. for all police candidates. Ald. Nick Sposato (38), a former firefighter, cast the sole “no” vote, arguing the department’s residency requirement was warranted. “I’m so troubled by this. I don’t think this is something I can support. I think we did everything right… We need a history, we need to know what these people were like.”

The suit alleges that between 2006 and 2011 the police department engaged in “national origin discrimination,” blocking 47 police candidates a spot on the force because they failed the residency requirement, said Notz.

“The requirement was designed to ensure that applicants had sufficient contacts in the United States for the department to conduct an adequate background check,” she explained. However, Title VII of the federal Civil Rights Act makes it illegal to discriminate against an employee because of his or her national origin, leading the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) to find the police department at fault. The department revised the policy to five years in August 2011. The new policy is not considered discriminatory, since only two candidates were turned down, Notz said.

A number of factors contributed to the $3.1 million figure. Under the settlement, the department has agreed to hire up to eight of the 47 applicants who were denied a spot on the police force. Each of the new hires will be eligible to receive retroactive retirement benefits (about $1 million). The city will also pay approximately $2 million in backpay damages and a $10,000 award to each of the two original plaintiffs, “in recognition of their assistance to the DOJ and EEOC.”

If the case had made it to court, Notz explained, the city could have been forced to pay out additional benefits to the denied police candidates and a court order could have forced the department to hire more than eight candidates.

The other two legal settlements the committee approved stem from allegations of police misconduct, or more specifically, illegal searches and seizures. Both had a smaller price tag: $200,000 and $220,000.

Municipal Depository Retraction - [Press release and draft ordinance.]

Ald. Jason Ervin (28) and Ald. Michael Scott, Jr. (24) directly introduced an ordinance into committee that would remove JP Morgan from the list of banks that can hold the city’s money in response to the bank closing a branch at 4114 W. Madison St. in East Garfield Park. It’s the only bank or ATM in the community, Ald. Ervin explained. Chairman Burke held the matter to give Ald. Ervin time to work the issue out with the bank and said it could be heard at the next meeting if no movement has been made.

McPier Building Permit Fee Waiver

Once-controversial building permit fee waivers for McPier that Chairman Burke held in committee after aldermen cried foul were brought up at the very end of the meeting, after the miscellaneous portion. Mike Merchant with the Metropolitan Pier and Exposition Authority testified for less than five minutes and it was quickly approved by the handful of aldermen that remained.

Back in January, after nearly 40 minutes of debate, Chairman Burke held two proposals that would have waived building and permit fees for the Metropolitan Pier and Exposition Authority, as well as a proposal that would authorize $7 million in TIF funds to pay for a new public park next to the Marriott Marquis Hotel currently being built. Some aldermen complained the city shouldn't be subsidizing private development.

But those in opposition were long gone by then. Ald. Pat Dowell’s (3) ordinance, if approved Wednesday, will save McPier roughly $2.6 million in construction fees associated with the McCormick Place expansion plan through 2017.

SSA Appointments Approved

The Committee quickly approved SSA appointments for:

• 
  

  John H. Idler, SSA 1-2015, the State Street Commission

  
  


• 
  

  Jacob Elkins-Ryan, SSA 8, the Lakeview East Commission

  
  


• 
  

  Nicol Vargas, SSA 18, the North Halsted Commission

  
  


• 
  

  Nickolas J. Cocalis, SSA 18, the North Halsted Commission

  
  


• 
  

  Luis A. Monje, SSA 27, the West Lakeview Commission

  
  


• 
  

  Paul F. Kartcheske, SSA 31, Greater Ravenswood Commission

  
  

An ordinance that would trigger special reporting from the State’s Attorney’s Office on big County financial settlements is up for consideration in the Cook County Finance Subcommittee on Litigation. The ordinance, sponsored by Commissioner Bridget Gainer and co-sponsored by Comm. Larry Suffredin and Comm. Peter Silvestri,includes a provision requiring the State’s Attorney’s office to release photo, video, or other relevant evidence in cases where the County seeks to settle for more than $500,000.

The ordinance was introduced weeks after the release of the Laquan McDonaldvideo, and after Cook County Commissioners John Fritchey and Jesus 'Chuy' Garcia called for State's Attorney Anita Alvarez to testify before the board on her role in the case. Comm. Richard Boykin has also called for a special prosecutor in future police shooting cases in the County, arguing the State's Attorney's relationship with police is too close to prosecute fairly.

In any settlement above that amount, the SA’s office would have to disclose potential conflicts of interest in the case, the employment status of County stakeholders named in the case, and “significant tangible evidence” like photos or video that are relevant to the settlement recommendation. The SA would also have to submit an annual summary of all cases settled for more than $500,000, and report regularly to the County’s Ethics Officer on county employees involved in settlements.

"As advocates for the best interests of all Cook County stakeholders it is our job as County Commissioners to ensure we are given all information in order to make decisions with millions of dollars of taxpayer dollars. Access to this information will also help serve as an additional safety-net for our critical first-responders: police officers, sheriff’s deputies, doctors, nurses and all Cook County employees,” Gainer said in a statement.